Pam Was Three Weeks From Closing Near Isle of Palms When a Car Payment Almost Killed Her FHA Loan
Pam was three weeks from closing on a house near Isle of Palms when her loan officer called with bad news. The deal was dead. Not because of her income, her credit, or the house itself. It was a car payment she had co-signed for her adult son years earlier, and it was about to push her debt-to-income ratio over FHA's limit.
A situation like Pam's comes up often for FHA borrowers. Someone co-signs a loan for a family member, a divorce assigns a debt to an ex-spouse, and years later that debt shows up on a credit report right when a mortgage application is being underwritten. Most borrowers assume the debt automatically counts against them because their name is on it. That assumption is what almost cost Pam her home.
What FHA Actually Says About Contingent Liabilities
HUD 4000.1, the FHA Single Family Housing Policy Handbook, addresses this directly. Here is the guideline, word for word:
"The Mortgagee must include monthly payments on contingent liabilities in the calculation of the Borrower's monthly obligations unless the Mortgagee verifies and documents that there is no possibility that the debt holder will pursue debt collection against the Borrower should the other party default or the other legally obligated party has made 12 months of timely payments. When a contingent liability is created by a divorce decree or other court order, evidence that the other legally obligated party has made 12 months of timely payments is not required."
In plain terms: if you co-signed a debt and the person actually responsible has made 12 straight months of on-time payments, that debt does not have to count against your ratios. And if a divorce decree or court order assigned the debt to someone else, you don't even need the 12-month history. The court order itself can carry the weight.
Why This Gets Missed So Often
Not every lender checks for this. Some treat any co-signed debt as an automatic inclusion because it is easier than pulling documentation and making the case to an underwriter. That is an overlay, not an FHA rule. It is a shortcut some lenders take that costs borrowers approvals they should have gotten.
For Pam, the fix was straightforward once someone knew to look for it. We gathered 12 months of her son's payment history on the car loan, showing consistent on-time payments, and documented the exclusion properly. The debt came out of her ratios and her file moved forward to closing.
What To Do If This Applies to You
If you have a co-signed loan or a debt tied to a divorce decree sitting on your credit report, don't assume it will sink your FHA application. Ask your loan officer this exact question: "Can this contingent liability be excluded under FHA Section II.A.4.b.iv.L, and what documents do you need?"
Then be ready with the paperwork. For a co-signed loan, that means 12 months of the other party's payment history, showing the payments came from their account, not yours. For a divorce-related debt, bring the divorce decree or court order itself. That single document can be enough.
This is exactly the kind of detail that separates a denied FHA file from an approved one, and it is why working with someone who knows where to look in the handbook matters. If you are carrying a co-signed loan or a court-assigned debt and you are wondering how it will affect your FHA approval, I'm Jason Sharon with Home Loans Inc, and I find the path. Call 843-LOW-RATE to talk through your file.
Equal Housing Opportunity. Home Loans Inc - Jason Sharon, Mortgage Broker. Company NMLS #1728740, Jason Sharon NMLS #1281448.
Learn more about this loan program: Pam Was Three Weeks From Closing Near Isle of Palms When a Car Payment Almost Killed Her FHA Loan