1 Percent: The Rule That Almost Cost Rachel Her Loan Approval
1 percent. That's the number that can quietly kill your loan approval if you have student loans in deferment and nobody tells you how lenders actually calculate them.
Rachel's Assumption
A situation that comes up often for buyers near Cottageville, SC, and beyond looks something like this. A buyer, we will call her Rachel, has student loans sitting in deferment. She is not making payments right now, so she assumes those loans will not count toward her debt-to-income ratio when she applies for a mortgage. It seems logical. No payment due, no impact on qualifying, right?
That assumption is one of the most common misunderstandings I run into with conventional loan buyers who have deferred student debt. It can catch a well-qualified buyer completely off guard, sometimes late in the process when there is little room to adjust.
What Conventional Guidelines Actually Say
Here is the guideline, word for word: "Monthly liabilities include installment loans, revolving debt, mortgage payments, alimony, child support, court-ordered payments, and student loans. Deferred student loans must be included using 1% of the balance or the documented payment."
Read that closely. Deferment status does not remove the debt from your file. A lender is required to count it using either 1% of the outstanding balance, or your actual documented payment amount, whichever applies to your situation. For a buyer with a meaningful student loan balance, that 1% calculation can be a real number, one that changes the debt-to-income ratio a lender uses to qualify you.
How This Plays Out
For a buyer in Rachel's position, the 1% of balance calculation ended up being the figure that mattered most for her file. Had that number not been calculated and accounted for upfront, it could have surfaced during underwriting instead, at a point in the process when a buyer has far less flexibility to adjust their plans.
The better approach is to have your loan documentation reviewed early. Pull your actual student loan statements and have your loan officer calculate both numbers, the 1% of balance method and your documented payment, before your file is ever submitted. That way you know exactly where your ratios stand before you are under contract, not after.
The One Question to Ask
If you have student loans in deferment and you are pursuing a conventional loan, ask your loan officer directly: "Can you pull my student loan documentation and calculate my payment using both the 1% of balance method and my actual documented payment, per Selling Guide B3-6-04, so we know which number applies to my file?"
That single question puts the calculation on the table early, instead of leaving it as a surprise.
I Find the Path
Deferred student loans do not have to derail your homebuying plans, but they do have to be accounted for correctly from the start. I am Jason Sharon, a licensed mortgage broker at Home Loans Inc, and I find the path for buyers navigating situations exactly like this one.
If you have deferred student loans and you are not sure how they will affect your approval, call me at 843-569-7283. Home Loans Inc - Jason Sharon, Mortgage Broker. Company NMLS #1728740, Jason Sharon NMLS #1281448. Equal Housing Opportunity.
Learn more about this loan program: 1 Percent