FHA Timing Trap: A December 31 Case Number Versus a January 1 Case Number

Priscilla is buying a home with an FHA loan. Her offer is accepted, her closing is lining up right around New Year's, and her agent has a simple plan: watch the closing date. It sounds reasonable. It is also the wrong date to watch.
Her situation is something that comes up often when an FHA purchase straddles the end of the year. Let me walk through it, because it matters to the agents and referral partners who guide buyers like her.
The rule in HUD's own words
The HUD FHA Alternative Credit Scores Preparedness Guide, issued with FHA INFO 2026-21, says this:
"Beginning with case numbers assigned on or after January 1, 2027, FHA will accept V4 and 10T credit score models in addition to Classic. All borrowers on a loan must be scored using the same credit score model(s)."
That is the whole rule, and two details deserve attention.
Detail one: it is the case number, not the closing
The trigger is the date the case number is assigned. It is not the contract date and it is not the closing date. Two buyers can close in the same week, yet if one case number is assigned on December 31 and the other on January 1, they sit on different sides of the line HUD drew.
That is the trap. An agent who tracks only the closing date may tell a buyer that new scoring options do or do not apply, based on the wrong calendar square.
Detail two: everyone on the loan is scored the same way
The second sentence says all borrowers on a loan must be scored using the same credit score model(s). If Priscilla has a co-borrower, the two of them are not mixed and matched. Whatever model or models are used, they apply to every borrower on the file.
For agents, that means a year-end FHA conversation is rarely about one person's credit alone. It is about the whole loan.
What V4 and 10T mean for your buyers
V4 refers to VantageScore 4.0. 10T is another newer scoring model. Classic is the model FHA has used. Starting with case numbers assigned on or after January 1, 2027, FHA will accept V4 and 10T in addition to Classic. I will not tell you which model is better for a given buyer, because that depends on the individual credit file. What I can tell you is that the date that decides which models are in play is the case number date.
The one thing you can do today
For FHA deals straddling year end, ask the lender when the case number will be assigned.
That single question does three things. It moves the conversation off the closing date. It tells you which side of January 1, 2027 the file is likely to fall on. And it gets your buyer and the lender on the same page before anyone makes assumptions about credit scoring.
You do not need to be a mortgage expert to ask it. You only need to know the question exists. Write it into your year-end checklist next to the inspection deadline and the appraisal date.
Why I raise this early
Calendar issues are easiest to handle when they are spotted early and hardest when they are discovered late. When a year-end FHA purchase comes across my desk, the case number timing is one of the first things I want to understand, because it shapes which scoring models are available and whether every borrower on the loan is scored consistently.
My approach is simple: I find the path. Sometimes that means a plain conversation about the calendar before anything else gets done.
If your buyer is in Priscilla's spot
If you have a buyer with an FHA purchase running across December 31 and January 1, I am glad to talk it through with you and with them. Call me at 843-LOW-RATE.
Home Loans Inc - Jason Sharon, Mortgage Broker. Company NMLS #1728740, Jason Sharon NMLS #1281448. Equal Housing Opportunity.
Learn more about this loan program: FHA Timing Trap

